Can You Measure Board Effectiveness?
View in browser

12/21/23 – Issue 8.47 – Your weekly news on all things board. 

Directors Domain Header 22

Happy Holidays! Boardspan and Director’s Domain wish you all the best in 2024. Director’s Domain will return after the New Year.

 

We all know thoughtful management succession planning is important, and events of last week underscored how important. But as the succession challenges between the Gildan board and the company’s CEO and founder show, even the best laid plans can be turned upside down. Board/CEO relationships can be a tightrope walk, especially when a founder is involved, and activists often see CEO transitions as the perfect opportunity for disruption. Gildan’s plight and Bernard Looney’s difficult exit from BP are good year-end reminders that a thorough succession planning review and/or strategy is a worthy 2024 resolution.

 

In other news, déja vu as familiar activists initiate new pushes; higher education boards face shareholder backlash; McKinsey omits cybersecurity from 2024 CEO priorities; the six types of board members; and, how can you measure board effectiveness?

 

In the Spotlight

 

Gildan Chairman Says Former CEO Flouted Succession Plan

Board stands behind his successor, Chamandy says he was terminated without cause

 

“Gildan Activewear said it is standing by its newly appointed CEO, Vince Tyra, after former chief Glenn Chamandy refused to abide by the company’s succession plan, according to a letter from the board on Wednesday. Chamandy wasn’t immediately available for comment. The board said while it credited Chamandy with building Gildan into a successful public company, he had struggled to find additional paths of growth and lost the board’s confidence. The board said it had a succession process for Chamandy underway for nearly two years and in September selected Tyra as chief executive officer.” THE WALL STREET JOURNAL

 

Major Shareholder Pushes Gildan to Reinstate Ousted CEO

Browning West holds a nearly 4% stake in the Canadian apparel maker

“A major and longtime shareholder in Gildan Activewear is pushing the Canadian clothing maker to replace its chairman and reverse a recent decision to oust its CEO…Browning West credits Chamandy with boosting the company’s earnings per share at a more-than-15% clip annually and wants it to reinstate him as CEO and a board member…The hedge fund is also asking the company to remove Donald Berg as chairman and initiate a search for his replacement.” THE WALL STREET JOURNAL

 

BP Claws Back $40 million from Bernard Looney

The board claims the former CEO misled them about personal misconduct

“BP cut over $40 million in remuneration from former CEO Bernard Looney after the British oil giant concluded he had knowingly misled the board over personal relationships with colleagues. BP's board dismissed Looney without notice effective Dec. 13 for serious misconduct and said in a statement on Wednesday he would receive no further salary or benefits from the dismissal date, and would not be paid an annual bonus for fiscal 2023…The dismissal cuts short Looney's 12-month notice period after he resigned in September for failing to fully disclose details of past personal relationships with colleagues. Looney's abrupt departure, after less than four years at the helm, threw the company into turmoil. The board is still seeking his replacement.” REUTERS

 

From Boardspan this Week:

 

REGISTER NOW: The Art of CEO Succession Planning: Secrets of a Winning Strategy

 

Tuesday, January 9, 2024

12pm ET


We’re kicking off 2024 with a deep dive into the CEO Succession Planning process with tips and insight from one of the most accomplished succession planners in the business. Join Boardspan CEO and founder Abby Adlerman and Chip Bergh, CEO of Levi Strauss & Co. and Chair of the board of HP, Inc., as he tells how he’s successfully navigated CEO succession planning many times, including planning his own successor.  We’ve already had an incredible response to this webinar, so reserve your spot while you can. 

Reserve Your Spot

 

Across the Board

 

Nelson Peltz to Nominate Himself, Former Disney CFO Jay Rasulo to Disney’s Board

Peltz and Trian Fund Management keep the pressure on for more board seats

 

“Activist investor Nelson Peltz said he plans to nominate himself and former Disney Chief Financial Officer Jay Rasulo to Disney’s board, weeks after the company rebuffed Peltz’s previous request to become a director. The announcement is the latest twist in a proxy battle between Peltz’s Trian Fund Management and Disney—the fund’s second campaign against the entertainment giant in a year—which has pitted the 81-year-old investor against 72-year-old Bob Iger, who returned to Disney a year ago for a second stint as CEO. Trian announced earlier this year that it had accumulated nearly 33 million shares of Disney stock and was seeking board seats for Peltz and at least one other, but Disney declined to add him to the board.” THE WALL STREET JOURNAL

 

Carl Icahn Prepares a Second Board Challenge at Illumina
As Illumina divests from Grail, Icahn says there is still work to do

 

“Activist investor Carl Icahn said on Monday that he plans to oust directors at Illumina, laying the groundwork for a second board challenge at the gene-sequencing company months after shareholders elected one of his director candidates. Icahn disclosed his plans without offering details in a letter to other shareholders less than 24 hours after Illumina said it will divest blood test maker Grail. The billionaire investor had long been critical of Illumina's $7 billion Grail acquisition and made it a centerpiece of his previous proxy fight in which Andrew Teno, a portfolio manager working for Icahn, won a seat on the 11-member board. In Monday's letter, Icahn blamed the Grail acquisition, which has faced regulatory challenges since 2021, for a 75% drop in Illumina's share price that he says wiped away $55 billion in value for shareholders.” REUTERS

 

Crown Castle Starts Fiber Review in Pact with Activist Elliott
Activist holding the company to its demands after taking a stake in 2020 

 

“Real estate investment trust Crown Castle Inc. is launching a ‘comprehensive’ review of its fiber business in a pact with activist investor Elliott Investment Management after the firm disclosed a $2 billion stake last month. Crown Castle is adding two independent directors to the company’s board including Jason Genrich, senior portfolio manager at Elliott, and Sunit Patel, former chief financial officer of Level 3 Communications Inc., the company said in a statement Wednesday. The company formed two special board committees, one to lead the review of the fiber business and another to conduct the search for a new chief executive officer.” BLOOMBERG

 

Drama at Harvard, Penn Puts Spotlight on University Board Oversight
Higher education boards receive new scrutiny

 

“They are lawyers, bank executives and donors. They run the nation’s most prestigious universities in their spare time. And, amid a national debate over antisemitism and free speech on college campuses, they are on the hot seat. University boards of trustees hold immense power over budgets, presidential picks and campus policies. They are also beset with longstanding challenges, including an often-unwieldy size, confusion over their responsibilities and limited relevant expertise. The boards of the University of Pennsylvania and Harvard University were at the center of a crisis recently after their presidents testified before Congress that calls for genocide of Jews may or may not violate campus codes of conduct, depending on the context. At Harvard, a unanimous board backed Claudine Gay, but Penn President Liz Magill resigned.” THE WALL STREET JOURNAL

 

McKinsey Omits Cybersecurity From 2024 CEO Priorities (Opinion)

Is it wise to downplay such a critical risk? 

“Digital era danger has never been higher, as the past year saw an unprecedented level of prominent, extremely disruptive and costly attacks. Insufficient corporate board cyber expertise and new SEC reporting rules only compound complexity. CEOs simply cannot afford to underestimate cybersecurity, relegate it to “IT project status” or outright omit it from c-suite agendas. The severe and common downside risks include strategy...” FORBES

 

6 Kinds of Board Members — and How to Influence Them

How to convey the right message to the right person

 

“There are many players trying to influence boards. Whether they are senior executives trying to get their ideas heard, consultants looking to sell business, or activist shareholders hoping to change the direction of an organization, they are all looking to influence and persuade the board…First, too many forget that influencing boards is about managing a range of relationships simultaneously. Board-level influence requires taking into consideration the position of each individual director, but at the same time never forgetting that board decision-making is a collective process where it is the truth supported by others — and not just held by one individual — that wins.” HARVARD BUSINESS REVIEW

 

How Do You Measure Board Effectiveness?

The methods and criteria are evolving

 

“Maximizing board effectiveness has been an ongoing and somewhat elusive corporate governance objective for U.S. corporate boards, executives and stockholders. While the board’s role in governance is well understood, the performance and outcomes of individual boards in terms of oversight, strategic input, advice to management and maximizing shareholder value, among other functions, are subject to significant variability depending on overall board effectiveness. The effectiveness of the board can mean the difference between serving as merely a required oversight function or serving as a valuable strategic and competitive asset. Achieving a high level of board effectiveness relies on the successful implementation of several key imperatives, including board leadership and composition, operational and deliberative processes, board culture and dynamics and performance evaluation and improvement.” HARVARD LAW SCHOOL FORUM ON CORPORATE GOVERNANCE

 

Activision Blizzard Will Pay $54 Million to Settle Discrimination Claims 

The controversy nearly jeopardized Microsoft’s eventual takeover

 

“Activision Blizzard has agreed to pay about $54 million to settle discrimination claims brought by California's civil rights agency on behalf of women employed by the video game maker. The settlement, which is subject to court approval, resolves allegations that the maker of Call of Duty, Overwatch, World of Warcraft and other video games “discriminated against women at the company, including denying promotion opportunities and paying them less than men for doing substantially similar work,” the California Civil Rights Department announced late Friday. Allegations of workplace discrimination helped drag down Activision’s stock price in 2021, paving the way for Microsoft's eventual takeover bid in January 2022.” YAHOO FINANCE

 

Nippon Steel to Acquire U.S. Steel for $14.1 Billion 

A new era for one of America’s oldest, largest steelmakers

 

“United States Steel agreed to be acquired by Nippon Steel in a $14.1 billion deal that would give the Japanese corporation a major role in U.S. steelmaking and end the independence of one of America’s oldest, most storied industrial enterprises. A takeover of U.S. Steel would make Nippon Steel, already one of the world’s largest steelmakers, one of the top suppliers to the American auto industry. The deal would give the Tokyo-based company access in the U.S. to specialized steel used in electric vehicle motors, along with steel used in appliances and construction materials.” THE WALL STREET JOURNAL

    Seat at the Table

    • First Citizens BancShares appoints to its board David Leitch, former Global General Counsel of Bank of America Corp

    • Wendy’s elects to its board Wendy Arlin, former EVP and Chief Financial Officer of Bath & Body Works

    • Kohl’s nominates to its board Wendy Arlin, former EVP and Chief Financial Officer of Bath & Body Works

    • Crocs appoints to its board John Replogle, former CEO of Burt’s Bees; and Neeraj Tolmare, Global Chief Information Officer at The Coca-Cola Company

    • Albertsons Companies nominates to its board Sarah Mensah, President of the Jordan Brand for NIKE; and Lisa Gray, Vice Chair and Senior Legal Officer of capital management firm Cerberus

    • Cracker Barrel Old Country Store elects to its board John Garratt, former President and CFO of Dollar General Corporation

    • Utility firm Ameren Corporation welcomes to its board Kimberly Harris, former CEO and President of Puget Sound Energy

    • Gildan Activewear adds to its board Chris Shackelton, Managing Partner of Coliseum Capital Management

    • Nikola Corporation elects to its board Jonathan Pertchik, former CEO and Managing Director of TravelCenters of America

    • Engineering firm Leidos nominates to its board Ann Norton, former Vice Admiral of the U.S. Navy

    • Peloton welcomes to its board Chris Bruzzo, former EVP and Chief Experience Officer at Electronic Arts

    • Marketing firm Omnicom appoints to its board Casey Santos, Chief Information Officer at IT firm Asurion

    • S&W Seed Company announces to its board Jeffrey Rona, Chief Business and Financial Officer of Ovid Therapeutics 

    • Streaming company Cineverse welcomes to its board Mary Halford, former Partner at Altman Solon

    • Solar energy firm Tigo elects to its board Sagit Manor, CFO of commerce payments platform Nayax

    LinkedIn
    Twitter
    Facebook

    About Boardspan
    Boardspan is the leading provider of digital governance solutions for boards across all sectors. Our cloud-based assessments, benchmarking analytics and governance education programs complement our board search and advisory services to deliver a holistic approach to governance. Boards of all sizes and stages rely on Boardspan to deliver analytics, insights and outcomes that improve their effectiveness and performance. Clients include KKR, The Kellogg Foundation, Ingersoll Rand, Farfetch, McAfee, Beyond Meat, Box, e.l.f. Beauty, Satellite Healthcare and the U.S. Olympic & Paralympic Committee.

    Copyright © 2023 Boardspan. All rights reserved.

    Boardspan updates its Privacy Policy in response to evolving best practices and regulatory requirements, such as GDPR. We value transparency and like to share these policies for use of our website and other information we offer.

    Boardspan, 3000 El Camino Real, Bldg. 4 Suite 200, Palo Alto, CA 94306, USA

    Unsubscribe Manage preferences