Boards Rethink Talent Strategies for a Challenging Economy
View in browser

10/2/25 – Issue 10.39 – Your weekly news on all things board. 

Directors Domain Header 22-1

Turbulent at the top. A spate of high-profile CEO exits this week, from mining to pharma to rail, underscores the challenges leaders face in an unstable economy. New CEOs are entering a pressure cooker of tariffs, cost inflation, and fickle consumer sentiment; they have little margin for error yet may also have less economic data available for decision making as the government enters a shutdown. Several high-profile companies, including Sweden’s Spotify, whose founding CEO Daniel Ek is moving into a strategic chairman role, and Oracle are betting that two at the top is better than one as they appoint co-CEOs to lead them into the future. Amid the tumult, several notable shifts are taking place: boards are recruiting more former CEOs whose experience is in high demand during these complicated times (leading to less diversity in the boardroom), while companies expand their C-suites, creating new leadership roles to effectively manage current opportunities and risks. This week's news suggests that boards are confronting economic uncertainty by doubling down on strategic expertise within the boardroom, the corner office, and across the C-suite.

 

In the Spotlight

 

Rash of CEO Ousters Signals Tightened Boardroom Leashes

From mining to pharma to railroads, boardrooms are making bold moves, signaling that performance, not pedigree, is what matters now

 

“It was the boardroom version of Black Monday: Four CEOs of big public companies were abruptly replaced yesterday. The exit of Barrick Mining’s Mark Bristow was a surprise, while that of rival Newmont’s Tom Palmer was better telegraphed. And CSX’s Joe Hinrichs, under pressure from a pair of activist hedge funds, was ousted effective immediately in favor of a 70-year-old executive with dealmaking chops. GlaxoSmithKline chief Emma Walmsley will leave the job in December, almost a year before her notice period expires (though she’ll be paid the full period), and just weeks after setting out her strategic plan for the drugmaker… It looks to be the most ax-heavy stretch since late September 2019, when WeWork, eBay, and Juul all fired their CEOs. HSBC’s executive chair Mark Tucker also stepped down without a permanent replacement, a leadership vacuum impactful enough to draw regulatory attention. (The departure of Spotify’s Daniel Ek, announced this morning, adds to the tally but with none of the drama; it’s an investor darling.)…. It has been an unforgiving year to be a big-company CEO. More than 1,500 chief executives have left through the end of August, the highest year-to-date….” SEMAFOR

 

Welcome to the Hot Seat: Retail’s New CEOs Get No Grace Period

Tariffs, margin pressure, and consumer uncertainty are leaving little room for rookie mistakes as leadership churn hits the retail sector hard

 

“Taking the helm of a well-known consumer company is the pinnacle of an executive’s career, but the current environment has left new leaders at companies like Nike, Starbucks and Peloton little time to celebrate…. Brian Niccol just hit the one-year mark at Starbucks and is trying to improve the experience of the coffee chain’s customers and workers. But he’s also dealing with higher coffee prices that follow double-digit tariffs on Brazil…. Nike’s Elliott Hill is about to hit his first anniversary in a role that entails bringing the sneaker brand back from a yearlong sales decline and getting more people pumped about it in a crowded footwear market…. The average tenure for a chief executive in consumer businesses was 5.9 years, down slightly from last year. That’s among the shortest in American business. At tech firms, for instance, the average was 10 years. In financial services, it was 8.7 years.” NEW YORK TIMES

 

From Boardspan this Week

P&G’s David Taylor on Culture, Activists, Crisis Readiness & More

Wednesday, November 5, 2025 | 2–3pm ET

 

Boardspan is excited to have David Taylor as Abby Adlerman’s next webinar guest. As the former Chair & CEO of P&G and current Chair of both Delta Air Lines and Opella (Sanofi’s consumer healthcare business), David has led global organizations through challenges and opportunities that create invaluable lessons for every board member.

 

 

Register Now

 

Across the Board

 

US Government Shuts Down

How it affects key economic data publishing

 

“The U.S. government shut down much of its operations on Wednesday after Republicans and Democrats failed to reach an agreement to extend funding past a midnight deadline, a closure that will shut off the flow of key economic data at a moment of uncertainty among policymakers and investors about the health of the U.S. job market, the trajectory of inflation and the strength of consumer spending and business investment.” REUTERS 

 

The Company Founders Who Think They Need Not One but Two Successors

After Netflix and Oracle, Spotify becomes the latest entrepreneur-run company to hand the reins to co-CEOs

 

“Finally convinced it is time to step aside, company founders often decide it takes two people to fill their big shoes—despite the mixed record of companies led by co-CEOs. Spotify’s Daniel Ek is the latest entrepreneur to be succeeded by a pair of chief executives. The music streaming giant announced Tuesday that co-presidents Alex Norström and Gustav Söderström will become its co-CEOs on Jan. 1. Oracle, founded by Larry Ellison, just announced its second pair of co-CEOs in 11 years. Comcast, too, picked a co-CEO to join longtime leader Brian Roberts, whose father founded the media company in 1963. Two heads are better than one, some boards reason, because they can bring complementary skills to the demanding role. The approach remains rare but has been particularly popular among entrepreneurs passing the baton…. Yet the arrangement often sets up a power struggle from the start, and many companies end up abandoning it before long.” WALL STREET JOURNAL

 

Building Resilience from the Top Down
In a world defined by disruption, high-performing organizations are those where directors and executives collaborate more fluidly, frequently, and strategically

 

“Across global markets, organizations continue to face challenges stemming from uncertainty, rapid change, and an array of risks…. A recent Deloitte analysis shows that many Fortune 500 organizations have added new C-suite roles, such as chief legal officer, chief transformation officer, and chief communications officer, to help ensure that the C-suite has the right skills and capabilities to capture opportunities and effectively manage challenges and risks. In this environment, it is perhaps no surprise that CEO tenure has reached its lowest point since Russell Reynolds began tracking it in 2018—a shift the firm attributes to ‘evolving role demands.’ The takeaway from these trends? Many CEOs—and their top management teams—may be seeking a different kind of engagement model with their boards, one that is more reflective of effective partnering and could offer challenge and support in equal measure.” DELOITTE INSIGHTS

 

The Modern Board Acts in Motion, Not in Meetings
When strategy must constantly evolve, boards can’t afford to wait for formal strategy sessions that occur once or twice a year

 

“The world is moving at breakneck speed, and a new study by Corporate Board Member and the EY Americas Center for Board Matters reveals just how dramatically this pace of change is reshaping corporate governance. In new research conducted earlier this year among nearly 200 public company board members, nearly three-quarters of directors say their corporate strategy is in constant flux, with six out of 10 saying they expect their carefully crafted plans to need complete overhaul within just 12 to 18 months…. The research reveals a changing dynamic in boardroom decision-making. While boards and management teams report strong alignment on current risks—with 87 percent of directors believing they see eye-to-eye with management on risk assessment—this consensus may be masking a more troubling issue: the potential for groupthink in an era when diverse perspectives are more critical than ever.” CORPORATE BOARD MEMBER

 

Board Diversity Stalls as White Men Reclaim the Majority

For the first time since 2017, white men make up most new S&P 500 board appointments

 

“Interviews with directors and recruiters make clear that boards are seeking candidates with experience as chief executive officers to help navigate economic and political turmoil, particularly tariffs. And because many of those executives began their careers decades ago, when leadership was less diverse, those being picked now are disproportionately White and male…. At the same time, recruiters say, efforts to broaden representation has slipped down boards’ priority lists amid the Trump administration’s backlash against diversity, equity and inclusion practices…. Through the pandemic and after, boards sought to bolster diversity and build their digital and human-resources expertise, areas with a broader pool of potential directors. Many of those hires now lead and sit on the powerful committees that decide who gets new board seats. They’re now asking recruiters to find leaders who have run companies or big business units, telling them that other considerations matter less.” BLOOMBERG

 

EA Goes Private in a Gaming Megadeal

A $55B leveraged buyout puts iconic franchises in private hands, illustrating how deep capital is reshaping entertainment, strategy, and boardroom priorities

 

“Videogame giant Electronic Arts will be taken private in a record-breaking $55 billion leveraged buyout by a consortium consisting of private equity firm Silver Lake, Saudi Arabia's Public Investment Fund and Jared Kushner's Affinity Partners, the company said Monday…. The take-private offer comes at a crucial time for EA, which is banking heavily on its core sports portfolio and action shooter intellectual property to weather a sluggish videogame industry as gamers get picky with spending.” REUTERS

 

Amazon’s Prime Tactics Trigger Record FTC Penalty

$2.5B later, the case serves as a warning shot for digital giants, and a call for stronger boardroom oversight of consumer-facing strategies

 

“Amazon agreed to pay $2.5 billion to settle Federal Trade Commission allegations that it duped customers into signing up for its signature Prime service and made it very difficult for them to cancel. The e-commerce giant will pay a $1 billion civil penalty, the largest in FTC history, and create a $1.5 billion fund to pay back to consumers, according to court documents. It will also be required on its Prime interface to include a simple way to cancel…. Amazon’s Prime membership, the largest paid subscription program in the world with at least 200 million users, has helped the company become an integral part of consumers’ shopping habits.” WALL STREET JOURNAL

 

Where Were the Directors? Investors Want More Than Silence

From Boeing to Meta, investors are demanding clearer answers on how directors respond, or fail to respond, when crisis hits

 

“Corporate scandals have always existed and many stem from weak corporate governance, often caused by a lack of communication, insufficient internal controls or a very lax attitude towards potential problems. In 2024, the US administration criticized Boeing’s board for failing to adequately supervise the safety procedures of its aircraft, following several accidents involving its 737 Max model that resulted in numerous deaths….  Also in 2024, Sam Bankman-Fried, founder and CEO of FTX, one of the world’s leading cryptocurrency platforms, was sentenced to 25 years in prison for defrauding his investors. In July of this year, the lawsuit filed by a group of small shareholders against the members of the board of directors of Meta, parent of Facebook, reached the oral trial stage before a settlement was reached. They had alleged that the directors were very lax in their supervisory duties…. A recurring question in these cases is around the extent to which the board is responsible for management decisions that may originate at levels of the company far removed from the board.” GOVERNANCE INTELLIGENCE

 

The Forecast on Quarterly Reporting

With EU and UK models showing little disruption, pressure is mounting in the U.S. to reconsider one of its longest-standing corporate requirements

 

“Every few years, the question arises as to whether quarterly reporting is the optimal timeframe for U.S. public companies. Now, with both President Donald Trump and Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) Chairman Paul Atkins as active proponents of ending quarterly SEC reporting, regulatory reform seems more likely than ever before.  Thanks to experimentation with reporting frequency in the European Union (EU) and the United Kingdom (UK), it is possible to make a few observations about potential reforms and a few predictions as to how regulatory change would affect financial reporting in practice. Overall, reducing reporting from a quarterly to a semi-annual schedule is likely to have less effect than either its critics fear or its proponents hope, as demonstrated by the EU and UK experience.” HARVARD LAW SCHOOL FORUM ON CORPORATE GOVERNANCE

    Seat at the Table

    • Boat retail firm MarineMax elects to its board Daniel Schiappa, President of Technology and Services at Arctic Wolf Networks

    • Payments technology firm ACI Worldwide appoints to its board Todd Ford, former President, CFO and EVP Operations at business financial management firm Coupa; and Didier Lamouche, former President and CEO of biometrics firm IDEMIA

    • Visa appoints to its board Bill Ready, CEO of Pinterest

    • FedEx nominates to its board Richard Smith, International COO and CEO of Airline at FedEx

    • Prudential Financial elects to its board Joseph Wolk, EVP and CFO at Johnson & Johnson

    • Quantum computing firm IonQ welcomes to its board General John W. Raymond, former first Chief of Space Operations for the U.S. Space Force

    • Industrial equipment manufacturer Terex Corporation appoints to its board Srikanth Padmanabhan, former EVP and President of Operations for Cummins

    • Flowers Foods names to its board Sterling Spainhour, EVP and Chief Legal Officer of energy firm Southern Company

    • Global Payments announces to its board Patricia Watson, former Chief Information and Technology Officer at fintech firm NCR Atleos; and Archana Deskus, former EVP and CTO of PayPal Holdings

    • Building products distributor BlueLinx elects to its board Christina Corley, President, International, and Vice Chair for technology firm CDW Corporation

    • Natural gas firm OPAL Fuels welcomes to its board Lance Moll, former President and CEO of FedEx Freight

    • Devon Energy adds to its board Brent Smolik, former President and COO at Noble Energy

    • Synchrony Financial elects to its board Deborah Ellinger, Senior Advisor at Boston Consulting Group

    LinkedIn
    Facebook

    About Boardspan
    Boardspan helps boards raise the bar on their critical governance mandates by combining cutting edge digital capabilities with high-touch consulting services. They are leaders in board assessments, individual director & CEO evaluations, board succession strategy & search, skills & composition analyses, and bespoke advisory work. Boardspan’s focus is entirely on boards, delivering deep experience, objectivity, an analytical orientation, and insight-driven recommendations. Boardspan works with public, private and non-profit organizations across all verticals including consumer, healthcare, financial services, technology, industrials and non-profit. Specific clients include Archer Daniels Midland, Autodesk, Blue Shield (CA), Boston Beer Company, Colgate-Palmolive, e.l.f. Beauty, HubSpot, Ingersoll Rand, KKR, Lam Research, the PGA, Roblox, Salesforce, the USOPC, and scores more.

    Copyright © 2025 Boardspan. All rights reserved.

    Boardspan updates its Privacy Policy in response to evolving best practices and regulatory requirements, such as GDPR. We value transparency and like to share these policies for use of our website and other information we offer.

    Boardspan, 3000 El Camino Real, Bldg. 4 Suite 200, Palo Alto, CA 94306, USA

    Unsubscribe Manage preferences