High Stakes: What’s Shaping Board Decisions Now
View in browser

12/11/25 – Issue 10.48 – Your weekly news on all things board. 

Directors Domain Header 22-1

Strategy in the crosshairs. At PepsiCo, a détente with Elliott Management produced sweeping operational commitments without a proxy fight or board overhaul, illustrating how activist influence can reshape strategy even without formal governance change. Siemens Energy finds itself in the early stages of an activist campaign seeking significant changes to its strategy, led by one of the founders of activist investor group Engine No. 1, which successfully targeted Exxon and won multiple board seats. Meanwhile, the Warner Bros. board is having a busy week: after agreeing to a $72 billion deal with Netflix, it finds itself with a rival bid from Paramount and the attention of President Trump, who promises to get personally involved in the government’s merger approval process rather than leaving it to the normal independent regulatory review. Elsewhere, Unilever’s ongoing conflict with Ben & Jerry’s independent board underscores the complexities of mission-based governance, two decades after their merger. And in parallel, AI continues to test boards both in terms of strategic relevance and the growing sustainability risks tied to its infrastructure. Boards operate in an increasingly high-stakes environment, where structure, strategy, and stakeholder alignment are constantly in motion.

 

In the Spotlight

 

Cost-Cutting with a Side of Quiet Activism

PepsiCo strikes a boardroom détente with Elliott, avoiding a proxy fight but promising reform

 

“PepsiCo struck an agreement with activist investor Elliott Investment Management, committing to cut costs across the company and lower prices in an effort to jump-start its slowing food business. The maker of Pepsi-Cola, Lay’s and Doritos said it would reduce expenses in its food and beverages operations, while cutting the number of individual products by 20% across its U.S. businesses…. The agreement doesn’t include Elliott representatives joining PepsiCo’s board…. The deal avoids a potentially long and costly battle between PepsiCo and Elliott, one of Wall Street’s most prominent activist firms. In September, Elliott unveiled a roughly $4 billion stake in the company, one of the firm’s largest equity positions ever, which ranked it among PepsiCo’s biggest investors.” WALL STREET JOURNAL

 

Activist Investor Pushes Siemens Energy to Focus on Gas

Founder of Ananym Capital, Charlie Penner, was the architect of Engine No. 1’s successful pressure campaign against Exxon

 

“Activist investment vehicle Ananym Capital has built a significant stake in Siemens Energy and is now urging the company to focus on its lucrative gas turbine and power generation business and spin off the much weaker wind power segment. Citing unnamed sources and a letter sent by the activist investor to the board of the German power utility, the Financial Times said Ananym Capital was doubtful about the profitability prospects of wind power but the gas turbine business had a bright future ahead, thanks to the data center-driven surge in demand for reliable, baseload generation capacity…. The Financial Times report noted that the founder of Ananym Capital, Charlie Penner, was the architect of Engine No. 1’s pressure campaign against Exxon…. launching a proxy fight that ended with the activist investor winning several seats on the board of Exxon.” YAHOO FINANCE

 

From Boardspan this Week

The Real Work of the Boardroom: Relationships, Rigor, and Readiness

 

Discover 6 key insights from our recent conversation with David Taylor, former P&G Chair & CEO and current Delta Chair, on boardroom best practices that, in his experience, enable boards to operate at their best.

Read Now

Across the Board

 

Paramount Launches Hostile Bid for Warner

Paramount’s move to outbid Netflix puts Warner’s board under pressure to defend its process and strategic rationale

 

“Paramount Skydance on Monday launched a hostile bid worth $108.4 billion for Warner Bros Discovery  in a last-ditch effort to outbid Netflix and create a media powerhouse that would challenge the dominance of the streaming giant. Netflix had emerged victorious on Friday from a weeks-long bidding war with Paramount and Comcast, securing a $72 billion equity deal for Warner Bros Discovery's TV, film studios and streaming assets. But Paramount's latest attempt means the jockeying for Warner Bros and its prized HBO and DC Comics assets will not come to a conclusion swiftly. The Warner Bros Discovery board of directors on Monday afternoon said it would review Paramount's offer, but was not modifying its recommendation with respect to Netflix. It advised the company to "take no action at this time" in regard to the Paramount Skydance proposal…. Larry Ellison called Trump after the Netflix deal was announced and told him the transaction would hurt competition…. The studio argues its bid for the entirety of Warner Bros Discovery is superior to Netflix, giving shareholders $18 billion more in cash and an easier path to regulatory approval.” REUTERS

 

Trump’s Shadow Looms Over Media Megadeal

Trump inserts himself into the Netflix–Paramount bidding war, breaking long-standing norms around regulatory independence

 

“On Sunday night, David Ellison, the chairman of Paramount Skydance, which is bidding against Netflix, had his chance to make his case face-to-face. Mr. Ellison was spotted in the presidential box with Mr. Trump at the Kennedy Center Honors ceremony in Washington. Hours later, Mr. Ellison unveiled a hostile bid to block Netflix’s acquisition — and in the fine print, revealed his version of a trump card: a private equity firm founded by Jared Kushner, Mr. Trump’s son-in-law, is onboard as an investor in the deal. Presidents are not supposed to influence the regulators who review major corporate deals, a process usually carried out at arm’s length from politicians’ whims. But with the future of the news and entertainment industries in the balance, Mr. Trump, himself a film and TV connoisseur, has broken precedent by placing himself directly in the middle of the sale of Warner Bros. Discovery, the biggest media deal of the decade.” NEW YORK TIMES

 

Ben & Jerry’s Chair Rejects Resignation Demands
Mittal said she is carrying out her role as chair with respect for the social mission and product quality responsibilities given to the board in Ben & Jerry's 2000 merger agreement with Unilever

 

"The chair of Ben & Jerry's independent board said she has no plans to resign as Unilever pressures her ahead of Monday's public spinoff of its Magnum ice cream division, which will include the Vermont-based brand. Magnum, a longtime division of the consumer goods conglomerate, said last month that the chair, Anuradha Mittal, ‘no longer meets the criteria’ to serve after internal investigations…. Magnum will list publicly on Euronext on Monday, and is inheriting a deepening corporate feud between Unilever and Ben & Jerry's, stemming from the politically progressive brand's stance on the Israeli-occupied Palestinian territories…. ‘It is important to understand that this is not simply an attack on me as chair. It is Unilever’s attempt to undermine the authority of the Board itself.’…. The board has sued Unilever twice in recent years, most recently accusing its corporate parent of censoring it over statements it wanted to make on Gaza.” REUTERS

 

AI’s Hidden Footprint Is a Boardroom Issue
The surge in data center demand is turning electricity and water into governance priorities

 

“AI now sits at the center of corporate sustainability governance as it supercharges data gathering, analytics, and reporting. Indeed, there is a clear upside for AI in areas of energy optimization, emissions monitoring, land‑use assessment, and climate scenario analysis. At the same time, AI’s rise is colliding with sharply growing electricity and water demands from data centers and concerns over geopolitically exposed supply chains. The governance challenge for companies therefore is to manage risk at this intersection…. AI has turned electricity and water from background utilities into constraints that should be dealt with on the board level. Indeed, AI magnifies water risk across cooling, power generation, and chip manufacturing.” THOMSON REUTERS

 

C-Suite Fumbles Start at the Top

Leadership transitions fail when boards and new executives aren’t aligned on communication, strategy, and scope

 

“The leap into the C-suite is often described as the pinnacle of an executive career. But for many, it’s also a precipice, with many leaders struggling to succeed once there…. They are leaders at the top of their game. So why do they stumble? The answer lies in the critical risks that often appear during the transition period—an executive’s first 12 to 18 months in role…. Not every new executive will have direct exposure to the board—but for those who do, the adjustment can be significant…. The board doesn’t run the business; it governs it. Like the CEO, the board operates at a different altitude than new executives are used to. Directors care about strategy, risk, and long-term value—not operational details.” HARVARD LAW SCHOOL FORUM ON CORPORATE GOVERNANCE

 

Director Support Hits Five-Year High

Despite record approval levels, cracks emerge around executive pay as shareholders scrutinize compensation more sharply

 

“In the 2025 proxy season, U.S. companies saw support for director reelections reach a five-year high of 94.2%, according to the Investor Stewardship 2025 report published by Diligent Market Intelligence (DMI). This strong backing for incumbent directors signals a notable shift in investor sentiment, reflecting heightened confidence in corporate leadership amid strong market conditions and a recalibration of priorities for board composition. This trend was particularly pronounced in major indices. During the 2025 annual meeting season (July 2024 - June 2025), director support in major indices rose significantly, reaching 96.3% in the S&P 500 and 95% in the Russell 3000, driven by strong markets and relaxed diversity mandates.” YAHOO FINANCE

    Seat at the Table

    • Disney names to its board Jeff Williams, former COO of Apple

    • Eli Lilly and Company elects to its board Dr. Carolyn Bertozzi, Investigator of the Howard Hughes Medical Institute

    • Honeywell appoints to its board Indra Nooyi, former Chair and CEO of PepsiCo

    • Logistics firm WESCO International welcomes to its board Michael Carter, EVP and Chief Partner Officer of Truist Financial; and David Wajsgras, former CEO of Intelsat Holdings

    • La-Z-Boy announces to its board William Boor, President and CEO of factory-built homes firm Cavco Industries

    • Industrial technology firm Aptiv adds to its board Håkan Agnevall, President and CEO of marine and energy firm Wärtsilä Corporation

    • Life sciences firm Avantor appoints to its board Sanjeev Mehra, Co-Founder and Managing Partner of private equity firm Periphas Capital LP 

    • Cybersecurity firm SentinelOne names to its board Mark Barrenechea, former CEO of OpenText

    • Perma-Pipe International elects to its board Richard Sherrill, SVP of Business Development for Howard Energy Partners

    • Gaming and Leisure Properties announces to its board Michael Borofsky, Founder of family office Mithrandir Ventures

    • Research firm Bruker welcomes to its board Jack Phillips, former President and CEO of Accelerate Diagnostics

    • Halozyme appoints to its board Jim Lang, former CEO of life sciences firm EVERSANA

    • Molecular diagnostics firm BillionToOne elects to its board Anthony Pagano, CFO and EVP of biotechnology firm Genmab

    • Murphy USA names to its board Michael Kulp, Founder and CEO of quick-serve restaurant chain KBP Brands

    • Biopharmaceutical firm Nuvalent adds to its board Ron Squarer, former CEO of Array Biopharma

    LinkedIn
    Facebook

    About Boardspan
    Boardspan helps boards raise the bar on their critical governance mandates by combining cutting edge digital capabilities with high-touch consulting services. They are leaders in board assessments, individual director & CEO evaluations, board succession strategy & search, skills & composition analyses, and bespoke advisory work. Boardspan’s focus is entirely on boards, delivering deep experience, objectivity, an analytical orientation, and insight-driven recommendations. Boardspan works with public, private and non-profit organizations across all verticals including consumer, healthcare, financial services, technology, industrials and non-profit. Specific clients include Archer Daniels Midland, Autodesk, Blue Shield (CA), Boston Beer Company, Colgate-Palmolive, e.l.f. Beauty, HubSpot, Ingersoll Rand, KKR, Lam Research, the PGA, Roblox, Salesforce, the USOPC, and scores more.

    Copyright © 2025 Boardspan. All rights reserved.

    Boardspan updates its Privacy Policy in response to evolving best practices and regulatory requirements, such as GDPR. We value transparency and like to share these policies for use of our website and other information we offer.

    Boardspan, 3000 El Camino Real, Bldg. 4 Suite 200, Palo Alto, CA 94306, USA

    Unsubscribe Manage preferences