View in browser

6/15/23 – Issue 8.22 – Your weekly news on all things board. 

Directors Domain Header 22

We seem to be in the middle of an ESG backlash. The number of anti-ESG bills introduced by lawmakers in 2023 has already doubled from 2022…and it’s June. Politicians and investors are challenging firms like BlackRock on their commitment to ESG and mission-driven investment. We’re seeing more “green-hushing” in investor communications, and companies like Bud Light and Target backpedaling their LGBTQ+-themed campaigns and marketing. Boards are a driving force for ESG initiatives. They will no doubt play a prominent role as advisors and thought leaders as companies determine how to react to pressure to dial back the emphasis on ESG.

 

In other news, Biogen faces board refreshment drama; Toyota shareholders re-elect Chairman Akio Toyoda; How to get governance right within SEC ESG requirements; and asset managers focus on director overboarding. 

 

In the Spotlight

 

Companies Downplay Mentions of ESG Initiatives in Earnings Calls, Elsewhere

An increase in “green-hushing” doesn’t seem to be affecting commitment to ESG action.

 

“Companies’ mentions of green and social initiatives during earnings calls have fallen off sharply in recent quarters, reversing a more boastful approach taken over the past few years amid intensifying pressure from some investors and conservative activists. Take electronic-signature firm DocuSign, where Chief Financial Officer Cynthia Gaylor in March 2022 said the company achieved carbon-neutral status during the year ended that January. Gaylor, who is set to step down as CFO on June 15, at the time said the company was continuing its efforts to reach net-zero emissions no later than 2050. The company’s executives haven’t mentioned sustainability initiatives, carbon-neutral status or net-zero emissions on its earnings calls since.” THE WALL STREET JOURNAL

 

Companies That Embraced Social Issues Have Second Thoughts

Bud Light, Target, and the North Face have pulled social campaigns. Will we see other companies hesitate to take a stand?

 

“CEOs spent the past few years adjusting to a world in which investors, customers and employees expected corporate leaders to align themselves with social causes. Today, that has made companies targets in the U.S. culture wars, where one step can turn a social-media storm into a corporate crisis that cripples businesses and wrecks careers. Some CEOs are rethinking how—or whether—to weigh in on sensitive political or social matters, with trans and other LGBT issues particularly in the spotlight.” THE WALL STREET JOURNAL

 

Investment Firms Feel Pressure to De-Emphasize ESG

Politicians claim BlackRock, Vanguard, and others are failing to honor their fiduciary duty. 

 

“But while many investors and fund managers want to use ESG frameworks to identify promising investments that also advance societal goals, some Republican lawmakers have argued they impose unnecessary constraints on corporations and undermine financial returns. At least 49 anti-ESG bills have been introduced across the US this year, according to the law firm Ropes & Gray. Twenty-two were introduced in 2022…(Politicians) argued that applying ESG to business decisions compromised financial returns, although the evidence is less clear-cut.” FINANCIAL TIMES

 

From Boardspan this Week:

 

Refreshing Your Board of Directors

Why refreshment and replacement are not synonyms.

 

"Corporate boards tend to change themselves during times of crisis—but otherwise accept the status quo. What if boards instead built regular, structured ‘refreshing’ of their membership, their processes, and their future needs into regular operations? What if boards went even further, not asking themselves ‘Do we need to change?’ but rather ‘What will we change?’ ‘Refreshing your board’ is a new phrase in the lexicon of corporate governance. Yet the phrase is already widely recognized among directors. For most, it evokes heightened expectations of a board’s competency and preparedness to govern.” THE CORPORATE BOARD via BOARDSPAN 

 

Across the Board

 

Biogen Struggles to Refresh its Board Amid Controversy

Replacement nominee had an undisclosed romantic relationship with departing board chair Alex Denner.

 

"Biogen, the $44-billion biotech company known for its work in Alzheimer's, is refreshing its board of directors. Often a sleepy affair, the process is now drawing attention in the biotech community. Alex Denner, a 53-year-old investor, is one of three people stepping down from the board. Standing for election as a replacement is Susan Langer, a 32-year-old biotech exec and former Biogen employee. What no one publicly disclosed is that Denner and Langer are romantic partners, and Denner is the father of Langer's child.” BUSINESS INSIDER

 

Denner’s Resignation Clears the Way for Activist Board Candidacy at Drugmaker Alkermes

Sarissa Capital founder is one of three Sarissa candidates running in activist push. 

 

“Activist investor Sarissa Capital may have cleared a stumbling block in its push for board seats at Alkermes when one of its candidates resigned from the board of a company that has a commercial relationship with the drugmaker. The hedge fund's founder, Alex Denner, 53, one of three Sarissa candidates running for seats on Alkermes' 11-member board, on Monday said he would give up his board seat at biotech company Biogen…Alkermes licensed multiple sclerosis drug Vumerity to Biogen for commercialization, and some analysts worried that it would be problematic for Denner to potentially sit on both companies' boards.” REUTERS

 

Digital Realty Director Resigns With a Bang

Former board chairman cites multiple governance issues in a lengthy letter.

 

“(Laurence) Chapman, 73, said that while he was chairman, he had asked three directors not to run for re-election as part of a plan for board succession. He cited one specific incident when he received a call from director Mark Patterson ‘saying I needed to get ‘those two women’ off the board’ in reference to two female directors appointed in 2020. Chapman said there were other issues with the director’s behavior, which he didn’t specify…Patterson said in an emailed statement that he disagreed with many of the assertions in the letters and believed in Digital Realty’s strong corporate governance practices.” BLOOMBERG

 

Toyota Shareholders Re-Elect Akio Toyoda to the Board

Activist investor concern over independence casted doubt on the longtime chair’s re-election. 

 

“Toyota Motor shareholders re-elected longtime leader Akio Toyoda to the board Wednesday, rejecting a push by some investor groups in the U.S. and Europe over his stance on electric vehicles. The company didn’t say what percentage of shareholders supported the renomination. Last year Toyoda earned 96% support. The company said the vote count would be released Thursday. Toyota shares were up more than 5% in Wednesday trading in Tokyo, to their highest level since early 2022.  Shareholders also rejected a proposal from three European asset managers including Danish fund AkademikerPension to make Toyota management reveal more about the automaker’s lobbying in favor of vehicles that aren’t fully battery-powered.” THE WALL STREET JOURNAL

 

Asset Managers Renewing Their Focus on Director Overboarding 

New policies address concerns that over-committed directors threaten the quality of board oversight.

 

“Recent governance policy refinements from several leading asset management firms are likely to create more work for the board’s nominating and governance committee. These new refinements recognize the governance risks arising from over-committed directors, and call on corporate boards to more aggressively confront issues of director overboarding. For most companies, the pressure to address director commitment concerns will be manifested in the development and maintenance of a formal overboarding policy and disclosure of how the board will monitor oversight of the rollout of such policy.” FORBES

 

How to Best Fulfill Governance Requirements in SEC ESG Rules

Strengthening the ‘G’ will help more boards more effectively address ‘E’ and ‘S’.

 

“For registrants to provide meaningful disclosures in line with the pay-versus-performance rules that help guide investors’ decision-making process, it is important that corporate management and boards of directors put into place controls and procedures to help ensure that material financial and nonfinancial information required to be disclosed is identified and communicated in a timely manner…While ESG matters are increasingly dominating executive and board agendas, the G — for governance — too often does not receive equal attention, which can rob registrants of the opportunity to leverage the power that comes from embedding risk management systems and other elements of sound governance into their corporate structures..” THOMSON REUTERS

 

Preparing for Corporate ESG Requirements From the Perspective of the CFO

Finance chiefs should focus on three areas: collecting data, tracking regulation and coordinating with ESG raters.

 

“Companies are increasingly tasking finance chiefs with developing systems to address environmental, social and governance issues, in the face of coming federal climate-disclosure rules and pressure from shareholders and employees. Chief financial officers need to create systems for collecting data to meet soon-to-be-unveiled new requirements from the Securities and Exchange Commission, while managing compliance costs…While it might sound tempting to centralize ESG responsibilities in the finance department, which already deals with data and reporting, consultants said that isn’t practical given the scope of requirements and breadth of corporate interests.” THE WALL STREET JOURNAL

 

What Matters Most in CEO Succession Planning

How to take a modern, holistic approach to one of the most important board responsibilities.

 

“In the past, boards often looked for a strong leader with a fixed, specific point of view. This might best be characterized as a dynastic succession model, which “grooms” a specific candidate for the CEO role. Such approaches can have merit, and some research does link this type of succession with improved firm performance…However, the shifting geopolitical and economic context of today’s operating environment means prioritizing different qualities, such as openness to innovation, humility, and agility. Thus, as both board members and companies have become more adaptive, so too has the candidate selection process.” HARVARD LAW SCHOOL FORUM ON CORPORATE GOVERNANCE

    Seat at the Table

    • Hewlett Packard Enterprise appoints to its board Bethany Mayer, former President and CEO of computer network company Ixia

    • Audio and video equipment manufacturer Roku welcomes to its board Jeff Blackburn, former VP of Global Media and Entertainment at Amazon

    • United Security Bancshares elects to its board Jay Gill, President and CEO of Gill Automotive Group

    • Graphite manufacturer GrafTech appoints to its board Diego Donoso, former President of Packaging & Specialty Plastics of chemicals corporation Dow

    • Jones Soda Company adds to its board Ronald Dissinger, former Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer of Kellogg Company

    LinkedIn
    Twitter
    Facebook

    About Boardspan
    Boardspan is the leading provider of digital governance solutions for boards across all sectors. Our cloud-based assessments, benchmarking analytics and governance education programs complement our board search and advisory services to deliver a holistic approach to governance. Boards of all sizes and stages rely on Boardspan to deliver analytics, insights and outcomes that improve their effectiveness and performance. Clients include KKR, The Kellogg Foundation, Ingersoll Rand, Farfetch, McAfee, Beyond Meat, Box, e.l.f. Beauty, Satellite Healthcare and the U.S. Olympic & Paralympic Committee.

    Copyright © 2023 Boardspan. All rights reserved.

    Boardspan updates its Privacy Policy in response to evolving best practices and regulatory requirements, such as GDPR. We value transparency and like to share these policies for use of our website and other information we offer.

    Boardspan, 3000 El Camino Real, Bldg. 4 Suite 200, Palo Alto, CA 94306, USA

    Unsubscribe Manage preferences