View in browser

9/28/23 – Issue 8.36 – Your weekly news on all things board. 

Directors Domain Header 22

“Succession” the prestige TV show may have ended a few months ago, but real-life succession is playing out across several businesses this week. Most notably, Rupert Murdoch announced last week that he is stepping down as chairman of Fox and News Corporation. His son, Lachlan Murdoch, will step into the big seat. What does it all mean for the media empire? As Murdoch fils makes changes on the Fox board, what other changes might we see? In a different kind of succession challenge this week, Amazon CEO Andy Jassy faces long-anticipated antitrust actions by the FTC. And Stanford is working to find a new president after its recent scandal. 

 

In other news, qualms about secrecy in Google’s antitrust trial; interview with an ESG shareholder activist; common themes in 2023 corporate governance; and new research finds boards coming up short on cybersecurity expertise.

 

In the Spotlight

 

In First Week, Lachlan Murdoch Shakes Up the Fox Board of Directors

Magic Leap CEO Peggy Johnson and former Australian PM Tony Abbott nominated to replace outgoing members

 

“A day after Lachlan Murdoch stepped up to take over as sole chairman of Fox Corp., the company is nominating two new members of its board of directors, according to a regulatory filing. Exiting the board is Anne Dias, who expressed concerns over how the company’s right-leaning news channel Fox News covered former President Trump in the days after the insurrection at the Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021. Dias, who runs an investment fund, and Jacques Nasser, a business executive and philanthropist, will finish their terms in November…Peggy Johnson, chief executive of the technology company Magic Leap, and Tony Abbott, a former prime minister of Australia, are the nominees to replace Dias and Nasser. Shareholders will vote on the nominees at the company’s annual meeting to be held Nov. 17 on the Fox studio lot in Century City.” THE LOS ANGELES TIMES

 

What Does Rupert Murdoch’s Exit Mean for His Media Empire?

Murdoch promises to still “be involved everyday in the contest of ideas.” 

 

“The news that Murdoch was stepping aside wasn’t a total shock. The media mogul is 92 and has struggled with various health issues, though he said in his announcement that he was in ‘robust health’……The biggest change could come internally when Rupert passes from this life. The Murdoch family, led by its patriarch, holds about 40% of the voting power in both Fox and News Corp., according to filings. When Rupert Murdoch dies, his votes in a trust that holds the shares will go to Lachlan and the patriarch’s three other oldest children. When that happens, Lachlan may not have the support of his siblings to stay in his role. The Murdoch children may even look to sell the family businesses.” BLOOMBERG

 

What to Expect With Lachlan Murdoch: More of the Same

Experts: Lachlan will likely preserve the conservative ideology of Fox and News Corp.

 

“When Rupert Murdoch formally hands over the reins of his media empire to his 52-year-old son Lachlan in November, die-hard Fox News viewers will hardly notice any difference. Conservative-leaning Lachlan has controlled the cable-news giant’s parent company since 2019, when he was picked to serve as chief executive and his more liberal brother James left the family business, seemingly ending speculation that a new sensibility would arrive with the next generation of Murdochs…In his note to Fox employees on Thursday announcing his departure, Rupert Murdoch described Lachlan as “a passionate, principled leader” and ideological descendant of his own late father, Keith Murdoch, who began the family’s media business. “My father firmly believed in freedom, and Lachlan is absolutely committed to the cause,” he wrote.” THE WASHINGTON POST

 

From Boardspan this Week:

 

Why is Succession Planning So Hard?

 

“Management succession planning is a challenge for boards. We know because they tell us. In Boardspan's 2023 Board Performance Benchmark Report, we ask boards to rate their performance in nearly 60 board governance topics. Every year that we’ve collected benchmarks, succession planning has been the Number One challenge for boards. It consistently tops a list full of challenging, meaty topics. Why? And more importantly, how do you get past the inherent difficulties and create a robust management succession plan?” BOARDSPAN INSIGHTS

 

Across the Board

 

FTC Lawsuit the Latest of Andy Jassy’s Succession Challenges 
As a “second-generation successor,” Jassy is working to resolve Amazon’s business and regulatory issues

 

“In the two years since Andy Jassy replaced Jeff Bezos as Amazon’s chief executive, he has been cleaning up after his company’s aggressive pandemic expansion and after Mr. Bezos. Mr. Jassy has reined in Amazon’s voracious warehouse growth, culled from the company’s sprawl of products and laid off thousands of employees on several of Mr. Bezos’ pet projects. On Tuesday, he was handed another challenge: a long-anticipated lawsuit from the Federal Trade Commission…Mr. Jassy joins other big tech chief executives who have taken control of enormous businesses from idiosyncratic founders at difficult moments. As with those other second-generation bosses, Mr. Jassy’s success will not only depend on whether he is a visionary like the man who started the company. It could also be shaped by how well he navigates the fears of Wall Street investors and the distrust of regulators in Washington…’He is cleaning up a mess that somebody else created,’ said Sucharita Kodali, an analyst at Forrester Research. ‘And he is doing it while trying to keep the ship afloat.’  THE NEW YORK TIMES

 

With Howard Schultz Gone, New Starbucks CEO Looks to Reset 
Laxman Narasimhan hopes to mend fractured relationship between the company and workers

 

“Distance between the executives who direct Starbucks’s corporate policy and the day-to-day trench warfare of serving Frappuccinos has left many of the chain’s 248,000 U.S. store workers fed up with senior management, demoralized and quick to quit. Short-staffed cafes saddled with unreliable equipment and rising quantities of online orders have contributed to clogged drive-throughs and long cafe lines. Baristas’ frustrations have fueled a unionization drive now entering its third year. Narasimhan says he gets it. Since taking the reins as CEO in March, he is working to boost store staffing levels, personally directing the revamp of problematic cafes and tackling spotty store inventories. At Starbucks’s headquarters, he is holding monthly get-togethers with rank-and-file workers, encouraging them to air frustrations. His ambition is to heal the relationship between the chain’s baristas and its corporate offices, which is hindering Starbucks despite record sales.” THE WALL STREET JOURNAL

 

Amid Multiple Challenges, Stanford Searches for a New President 

Marc Tessier-Lavigne’s resignation, the FTX scandal, underscore need for intentional leadership

“‘It’s an opportunity for (Stanford) to gauge where they are and take into account all the things that have happened and the general direction of the institution,’ said Bill Funk, whose firm has conducted searches for university presidents over the last 35 years, including for the University of California system, Cornell University and Texas A&M University. Even amid the challenges, it’s likely to be a highly sought-after job, he said. Earlier this month, Stanford named a 20-person search committee of alumni, faculty and current students. It’s co-led by Gene Sykes, the co-chair of global mergers and acquisitions at Goldman Sachs Group Inc.; Lily Sarafan, co-founder and executive chair of home-care company The Key; and Bonnie Maldonado, Stanford’s senior associate dean of faculty development and diversity and a professor of pediatrics and infectious diseases. ’More than just finding an individual to serve in that capacity, this is an opportunity for us to collectively shape the future of our university, and to help write the next chapter for how Stanford will lead,’ Jerry Yang, the Yahoo co-founder who’s the chairman of the board of trustees, said in a Sept. 14 statement announcing the committee.” BLOOMBERG

 

New Research: Boards Still Lack Cybersecurity Expertise

Only 12% of S&P 500 companies have board members with relevant cyber credentials

 

“An analysis of board composition in companies in the S&P 500 index found that 88% have no cybersecurity expert as a director. Only seven companies had a current or former chief information security officer on their board, the research found, and in two cases, that was the same person.‘This lack of momentum in the boardroom continues to startle me,’ said Dave DeWalt, founder and chief executive at venture-capital firm NightDragon, who also sits on the boards of Delta Air Lines and software company Five9…Cyber expertise was broadly defined as people who currently work or formerly worked in CISO roles; those who held senior technology positions, but not necessarily cyber roles; and those who had technology experience without having held senior positions…About 52% of companies had a board director with some technology experience adjacent to cybersecurity. This includes people who sit on the boards of cyber companies or have an affiliation with a cybersecurity-related professional organization.” THE WALL STREET JOURNAL

 

Shareholder Activism in Practice, from an ESG Watchdog Group 

An interview with Brynn O’Brien from the Australasia Centre of Corporate Responsibility 

 

“Brynn O’Brien is talking about the tedious world of tracking companies’ greenhouse gas emissions. While it’s seldom described this way, O’Brien is specifically referring to the contradiction between corporations making big claims in their climate ledgers and facing zero repercussions if their carbon accounting isn't as rigorous as their financial accounting. Emissions, O’Brien says, are ‘absolutely material financial risk,’ and her organization intends to hold companies responsible for them…O’Brien is the executive director of the Australasian Centre for Corporate Responsibility, a shareholder activist organization that keeps careful watch on the climate plans of companies in which it owns shares…A human rights lawyer before becoming a shareholder activist, O’Brien says engaging a company from within is also more effective at cutting emissions than simply divesting…ACCR has been part of some impressive wins. The organization was part of an initiative to replace the board of directors of AGL, an Australian utility and the country’s largest emitter; now AGL is investing in renewables. ACCR is also pushing mining giant Glencore to curb its coal investments — the company has already backed down from one mine — and is part of a greenwashing lawsuit against Santos over the oil giant’s net-zero strategy.” BLOOMBERG

 

Google Pushes to Limit Disclosures in Antitrust Trial 

Efforts to limit transparency by Google, others make this the most secretive antitrust trial in decades

 

“The upshot is that last week, more than half of the testimony in the trial was given behind closed doors, according to one analysis. When one witness, the chief executive of the search engine DuckDuckGo, testified on Thursday, he spoke on the stand for nearly five hours — of which just one hour was open to the public. At the judge’s request, the Justice Department, which is one of the plaintiffs, has also removed its presentations and evidence from the open web. The lack of transparency continued this week as a top Apple executive, Eddy Cue, testified on Tuesday about a crucial search agreement that Apple struck with Google. The federal government has accused Google of illegally using agreements with companies like Apple to maintain its monopoly in online search and to crush rivals…’The secrecy surrounding the proceedings is unprecedented in antitrust trials,’ Diane Rulke, an organizational behavior professor at Carnegie Mellon, said in an interview. Four other antitrust experts interviewed by The Times also described the proceedings as unusually opaque, adding that the government’s antitrust case against Microsoft more than 24 years ago was far more accessible to the public and the press.” THE NEW YORK TIMES

 

2023 Corporate Governance Developments 

As we head toward year’s end, a look at the hot topics for boards and committees in 2023

 

“Many boards are seeking a general understanding of AI, how their companies and peers are using it, and potential risks and concerns arising from the use of AI, including any cybersecurity, privacy and other liability issues, as well as employee and ethical implications. Although there is not one correct approach for overseeing AI risks, boards of companies that rely on AI for material products, services or operations (or relevant committee members) may want to consider receiving training on AI and associated risks, as well as management reports on the company’s use of AI…In light of the agenda‑ed October release of the SEC’s final climate disclosure rules (which will likely require detailed information and third-party attestation of GHG emissions metrics and may require the inclusion of climate-related information in audited financial statements) and the adoption of international sustainability reporting standards and frameworks that may be applicable to certain U.S. companies, audit committees may need to establish and oversee disclosure controls and procedures for climate and other sustainability disclosures…With director overboarding a recurring investor concern and the Department of Justice and FTC increasingly scrutinizing interlocking directorates for potential Clayton Act issues, nominating and governance committees should review the outside board memberships and other employment affiliations of their directors to ensure such service aligns with the current overboarding expectations of their top investors and also does not raise potential Clayton Act or conflict of interest issues.” HARVARD LAW SCHOOL CENTER FOR CORPORATE GOVERNANCE

    Seat at the Table

    • KKR welcomes to its board Kimberly A. Ross, former CFO of WeWork

    • Fox Corporation nominates to its board Margaret “Peggy” L. Johnson, CEO of Magic Leap, and Tony Abbott, former Prime Minister of Australias

    • Dell Technologies appoints to its board Steve Mollenkopf, former CEO of Qualcomm

    • CVS Health welcomes to its board Michael F. Mahoney, Chairman and CEO of Boston Scientific

    • Nordstrom appoints to its board Guy B. Persaud, President, New Business Unit, Procter & Gamble

    • Instacart welcomes to its board Ravi Gupta, Partner at Sequoia Capital and former CFO and COO of Instacart

    • Western Union elects to its board Suzy Deering, former Global CMO of Ford Motor Company

    • Lennar elects to its board Dacona Smith, former EVP and COO of Walmart

    • GSK welcomes to its board Wendy Becker, Chair of Logitech

    • Flowserve appoints to its board Cheryl H. Johnson, CHRO at Caterpillar

    • NextEra Energy appoints to its board Maria G. Henry, former CFO of Kimberly Clark

    LinkedIn
    Twitter
    Facebook

    About Boardspan
    Boardspan is the leading provider of digital governance solutions for boards across all sectors. Our cloud-based assessments, benchmarking analytics and governance education programs complement our board search and advisory services to deliver a holistic approach to governance. Boards of all sizes and stages rely on Boardspan to deliver analytics, insights and outcomes that improve their effectiveness and performance. Clients include KKR, The Kellogg Foundation, Ingersoll Rand, Farfetch, McAfee, Beyond Meat, Box, e.l.f. Beauty, Satellite Healthcare and the U.S. Olympic & Paralympic Committee.

    Copyright © 2023 Boardspan. All rights reserved.

    Boardspan updates its Privacy Policy in response to evolving best practices and regulatory requirements, such as GDPR. We value transparency and like to share these policies for use of our website and other information we offer.

    Boardspan, 3000 El Camino Real, Bldg. 4 Suite 200, Palo Alto, CA 94306, USA

    Unsubscribe Manage preferences