View in browser

7/13/23 – Issue 8.25 – Your weekly news on all things board. 

Directors Domain Header 22

“Project 42” sounds mysterious, and it is: the unusual glass structure adjacent to Tesla’s plant in Texas might be a residence for CEO Elon Musk. Or it might not. Is Musk using Tesla funds for a private residence? A multimillion-dollar order for special glass has sparked an internal probe of the project by the Tesla board and others. What is Project 42 and who’s paying for it? We’re sure there’s more to come.

 

In other news, the PGA Tour board faces Senate questioning of the PGA Tour/LIV Golf merger; a federal court gives Microsoft the go-ahead for its $69 billion acquisition of Activision Blizzard; and the critical role the board plays in marketing strategy. 

 

In the Spotlight

 

At Tesla, Internal Probe Sparked by Expenses for Mysterious Glass Building

Internally, “Project 42” was described as a house for Elon Musk

 

“Inside Tesla, it was known as ‘Project 42,’ and the plans called for a dramatic glass-walled building to rise near the automaker’s headquarters…Tesla board members investigated whether company resources had been misused and if Musk, himself, had a role…It is rarer for boards to sign off on using corporate funds for personal homes, corporate governance experts say, though it may happen related to portions of homes used for work purposes, such as meeting rooms for executives or board gatherings. Tesla has said in securities filings that the board’s audit committee must review and approve transactions above $120,000 in which a related person, such as an executive officer, has a material interest.” THE WALL STREET JOURNAL

 

What is “Project 42”?

The seemingly personal nature of the project and costly expenditures raised questions

 

“The project previously drew scrutiny within the company after an order for glass made as part of the building-planning efforts. At the time, the internal inquiry into the order had targeted Omead Afshar, an executive leading Tesla's Texas factory…Tesla's board had also inquired into any involvement by Musk in the project, and also the amount of time any employees had spent on it…The project appeared to be for a ‘dramatic glass-walled building’ close to Tesla's headquarters in Texas…concept plans showed differing designs and features, but included residential elements like bedrooms.” BUSINESS INSIDER

 

From Boardspan this Week:

 

JUST RELEASED: Boardspan’s 2023 Board Performance Assessment Benchmark Report

Insights on board trends, challenges, strengths, and more

 

It’s benchmark season: We’re pleased to share the 2023 Board Performance Assessment Benchmark Report, now available for free download. It’s our seminal report on the analysis and insights from our board benchmarks. Our benchmarks are based on board responses to nearly 60 questions across nine categories of board governance and performance. Where are boards focusing their efforts in 2023? What is most challenging? Where do we see growth? It’s all in the report. We hope you find it useful—tell us what you think!

GET THE REPORT

 

Across the Board

 

The PGA Tour Board Faces Senate Questioning About LIV Golf Merger

Lawmakers concerned about antitrust issues, human rights record in Saudi Arabia
 

"Senate Democrats and Republicans grilled PGA Tour officials over their plans to merge with the Saudi-backed LIV Golf during a Tuesday hearing. The Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations heard testimony from PGA Tour Chief Operating Officer Ron Price and board member Jimmy Dunne, who argued a proposed framework for the deal would allow expensive legal fights and fracturing player and fan base to end…The hearing comes a month after the PGA Tour, the world's leading professional golf league, agreed to merge with LIV Golf, the Saudi-funded upstart league.” NPR

 

Federal Judge Rules in Favor of Microsoft/Activision Merger

The $69 billion deal could be finalized within days

 

“A federal judge will not block Microsoft (MSFT) from closing its $69 billion deal to acquire video game giant Activision Blizzard, a defeat for US regulators who had asked for a temporary injunction while legal challenges to the merger unfold. The decision not to grant the injunction by the US District Court for the Northern District of California clears the way for Microsoft to consummate a deal that will make it the third largest video game publisher in the world…US antitrust officials at the Federal Trade Commission had argued that an injunction temporarily blocking the deal was necessary because allowing the merger to close amid ongoing litigation would have caused immediate harm to video gamers and other consumers.” CNN

 

Microsoft-Activision Ruling Represents Another Setback for the FTC

Chair Lina Khan wants to toughen antitrust enforcement, but so far fights a losing battle in court

 

“When a federal judge in California rejected the US Federal Trade Commission’s request to block Microsoft’s $75bn (sic) acquisition of Activision Blizzard, she dealt a sharp setback to the regulator’s ambitious effort to toughen antitrust enforcement under chair Lina Khan. Judge Jacqueline Scott Corley ruled on Tuesday that the FTC had failed to prove that the megamerger would harm competition in the video game industry. The details of her ruling revolved around whether Microsoft would limit its rival Sony’s access to blockbuster Activision game Call of Duty, but the decision’s resonance in Washington and corporate America will be much broader.” FINANCIAL TIMES

 

Why Board Engagement in Company Marketing Efforts is Imperative

To safeguard and uphold a brand’s reputation, board oversight must extend to marketing strategy

 

“As the business landscape becomes increasingly competitive, brands and organizations are constantly seeking innovative ways to expand their marketing efforts to reach new audiences. In this pursuit, the board of directors should be invited to join the marketing conversation not just to fulfill its oversight responsibilities, but to view the proposed marketing efforts through the lens of both customers and stakeholders, and, in some cases, to avoid a crisis communication nightmare” DIRECTORS & BOARDS

 

Five Essential Strategy Questions Boards Should Be Asking

Focusing on five critical topics will help elevate board performance and strategic value

 

“Boards and C-suites alike have an opportunity to recalibrate their risk framework to focus on a longer-term horizon and reframe the discussion from risk to opportunity. This could include opportunities related to innovations around technology, changing consumer expectations, strategic transactions and evolving business models, all of which could impact how the company is doing business in five years and beyond. Consideration should also be given to the strategic ways technology and data can be used to improve the ability to identify and capture emerging opportunities and accelerate growth.” EY via BOARDSPAN

 

The Importance of Strategic Minds for Effective Governance

CEOs and Directors find strategic competency via collaboration

 

“The relationship between governance and strategy in organizations has long been tenuous. CEOs often view governance merely as a regulatory requirement, delegating it to the CFO, auditors, and legal experts, with only scripted meetings with the board…But directors, especially those representing large passive investment funds, are hesitant to delve into strategy due to their fiduciary responsibility. CEOs often fail to establish a collaborative relationship with the board, maintaining a distance that gives them autonomy but impedes strategic thought. They can overcome this divide by developing a shared strategic perspective on the future.” INSEAD

 

More Insights from Boardspan

 

5 Things Boards Should Consider When It Comes to AI

Ethics, policy, technology, and more

 

Why is Governance Planning Important?

A tale of two boards

 

The Essentials of Alignment

If boards aren’t aligned, it’s hard to get much done

    Seat at the Table

    • Boardspan congratulates Margaret Lazo, Senior Operating Consultant at private equity firm Cerberus Capital Management, on her appointment to the board of Heartland Financial USA. Boardspan is delighted to have advised Heartland Financial USA on this placement 

    • Communications software company Movius elects to its board Lisa Davis, EVP and Chief Information Officer at Blue Shield of California 

    • Hydrogen solutions firm Plug Power welcomes to its board Patrick Joggerst, Principal and Founder of management consulting firm J2 Consulting; and Mark Bonney, President and CEO of On Board Advisors

    • Adicet Bio appoints to its board Katie Peng, Chief Commercial Officer at Denali Therapeutics 

    • Pharmacy care firm Omnicell elects to its board Bobby Ghoshal, President of SaaS for medical equipment company ResMed 

    • Vaccine delivery company PharmaJet welcomes to its board Dr. Nanette Cocero, former Global President of Pfizer Vaccines 

    • Valvoline appoints to its board Patrick Pacious, President and CEO of Choice Hotels International

    • Bread Financial Holdings adds to its board Joyce St. Clair, former Executive Vice President and Chief Human Resources Officer of investment bank Northern Trust 

    • Neobank Dave appoints to its board Yadin Rozov, former Partner at GoldenTree Asset Management 

    • Asset manager ALTi Global elects to its board Norma Corio, former Senior Managing Director and Head of Capital Markets at One Equity Partners

       

    LinkedIn
    Twitter
    Facebook

    About Boardspan
    Boardspan is the leading provider of digital governance solutions for boards across all sectors. Our cloud-based assessments, benchmarking analytics and governance education programs complement our board search and advisory services to deliver a holistic approach to governance. Boards of all sizes and stages rely on Boardspan to deliver analytics, insights and outcomes that improve their effectiveness and performance. Clients include KKR, The Kellogg Foundation, Ingersoll Rand, Farfetch, McAfee, Beyond Meat, Box, e.l.f. Beauty, Satellite Healthcare and the U.S. Olympic & Paralympic Committee.

    Copyright © 2023 Boardspan. All rights reserved.

    Boardspan updates its Privacy Policy in response to evolving best practices and regulatory requirements, such as GDPR. We value transparency and like to share these policies for use of our website and other information we offer.

    Boardspan, 3000 El Camino Real, Bldg. 4 Suite 200, Palo Alto, CA 94306, USA

    Unsubscribe Manage preferences