CANDIDATES
Candidate Toolkit |
THE BOARDSPAN LIBRARY
The Boardspan staff reviews and selects the most informative articles from business news sources, including:





We categorize articles to make them easier for you to find.
- Exec. evaluation & comp
- Critical information about evaluating and compensating the executive team.
Beware Financial Mishaps at Nonprofits

Why board members miss the red flags
Nonprofits Assistance Fund is sometimes called in to help nonprofits when they have financial problems that have been building for a long time. Fortunately, financial turnarounds are possible and we’ve seen some incredible work at nonprofits that resulted in financial recovery. Whether the outcome is positive or negative, though, in every case the situation would have been more manageable if it had been identified and addressed sooner. At some point, the question comes up: why didn’t someone, including board members, see the red flags and call attention to them sooner?
There are hundreds of reasons, of course, including disengaged boards, weak fiscal controls, misunderstanding of roles and responsibilities, and lack of timely information. I’ll offer one technical reason: boards miss the red flags because they don’t know where to find them.
But red flags should be obvious on the financial reports, right? Not really.
Some background: there are two standard financial reports that should be provided to the board of directors regularly, the income statement and balance sheet. From all the training workshops we’ve delivered over the years we know that the income statement makes sense to most people, especially when the report includes a comparison to the budget for the same period. With some basic training board members can get comfortable reviewing how much income is coming in, what the expenses have been, and where the actual performance varies from budget. Balance sheets, on the other hand, are not easy to read or interpret. They are based on accounting terminology and standards that require more training and experience to make them useful. Nonprofit accounting rules for restricted funds make balance sheets complex even for experienced finance professionals from the business sector. It’s hard for board members to get a handle on what’s important on the balance sheet or feel comfortable asking questions.
So, why do board members miss the financial red flags?
Boards pay too much attention to income statements and budgets.
The periodic income statement is useful for tracking progress and expense controls, but this report is very limited because it is covers such a short time period. Big variances are useful to alert boards to questions. Deficits are cautionary signs that deserve analysis. A surplus or a deficit in one month, or even one year, is usually not the sign boards need. What matters is the cumulative financial condition over time, signs that indicate a big problem that threatens a nonprofit’s future.
Boards don’t pay enough attention to balance sheets.
Many (most?) board members pass over the balance sheet or skim it, at best. That’s too bad, because the balance sheet is the key for seeing the problems. The balance sheet reports the cumulative effect of all of a nonprofit’s financial activity over the years and signals financial health or problems. Healthy nonprofits build up assets, cash reserves, and unrestricted net assets, and maintain reasonable amounts of debt. Nonprofits with serious financial problems report diminishing cash, insufficient working capital, restricted funds diverted to current operations, negative unrestricted net assets, and creeping debt levels. Those are the red flags that should make board members jump up and down and shout – look over here.
Yellow flags are on the income statement. Slow down, look both ways. Red flags are on the balance sheet. Stop – now!
Republished with permission from Nonprofits Assistance Fund. To learn more, visit nonprofitsassistancefund.org
MORE ARTICLES
Refreshing Your Board of Directors
Patrick R. Dailey, Ph.D. and Joel M. KoblentzMore Female Board Directors Add Up to Improved Sustainability Performance
U.C. Berkeley, Haas School StaffBoard Governance Depends On Where You Sit
William GeorgeBattle For the Boardroom
Ludo Van der Heyden and Chris HowellsNight of the Living Board
Matt PalmquistThe "Third Team" Approach to Board Effectiveness
Denis Mowbray and Coral Ingley (both from Auckland University of Technology)Tapping The Strategic Potential of Boards
Chinta Bhagat, Martin Hirt, and Conor KehoeLean Strategy Not Just For Start-Ups
Carmen NobelInvolving the Board in Strategic Planning
Jean-Daniel BrissonBest Practices: Non Profit Governance
McDermott Will & EmeryValue-Focused Corporate Governance
Christian Orglmeister, Marcos Aguiar, and Daniel AzevedoTen Key Dimensions of Effective CEO Succession
Thomas J. SaporitoThe Trouble With Too Much Board Oversight
Olubunmi Faleye, Rani Hoitash and Udi HoitashPurpose, Vision, Mission, Values
Graham KennyRunning More Effective Board Meetings
Mark SusterA More Effective Board of Directors
Ana DutraCulture & Business Performance: What’s the relationship?
Method Frameworks StaffCorporate Culture, Not Lip Service, Counts
Luigi Guiso, Paola Sapienza and Luigi ZingalesBuilding a Forward-looking Board
Christian Casal and Christian CasparWhen Best Practice Isn't Enough
Simon C. Y. WongCollaborate Better
Leigh ThompsonThree Critical Talent Conversations For Every Board of Directors
Jean Martin and Michael GriffinOutgoing CEOs Shouldn't Pick Their Replacements
David F. Larcker, Stephen A. Miles, and Brian TayanFive Things Every CEO Must Do in the Next Era of Globalization
Hans-Paul Bürkner, Arindam Bhattacharya, and Jorge BecerraD&O Liability Insurance: An Overview
Priya Cherian HuskinsBest Practices in Compliance
Stefanie MoscaWhy Every Company Needs a Board of Directors
Brian HamiltonWhy Leadership Isn't Just For Leaders
Sally Helgesen10 Principles of Leading Change Management
DeAnne Aguire and Micah AlpernThe Double-Edged Sword of CEO Activism
David F. Larcker, Stephen A. Miles, Brian Tayan, and Kim Wright-ViolichThe Buck Stops and Starts at the Top
Cathy L. Reese, John Michael Farrell & Jose SierraBeware Financial Mishaps at Nonprofits
Kate Barr4 Ideas for Improving Effectiveness & Reducing Risk
Stuart M. AltmanPlanning Ahead – The Board’s Role in Crisis Management
M. Hill Jeffries, Kyle G. Healy, Marshall M. ChalmersThe Economic Case for Soaring CEO Pay
Anup SrivastavaSurviving the Sophomore Slump: Moves That Matter The Most
Roselinde Torres, Judy Johnson, James M. Citrin, and Susan S. HartLeapfrog Succession: Trend in Appointing CEOs
Roselinde Torres, Gerry Hansell, Kaye Foster, and David BaronWhy Clawback Provisions Are a Must: Present and Future Risks in Financial Services
Brian Jebb and Sarah HenchozCan Cutting CEO Pay Help a Faltering Company Rebound?
Emily AyshfordWhy Senior Leaders Are On The Front Line Against Cyberattacks
Tucker Bailey, James Kaplan, and Chris RezekCorporate Data Privacy: Time To Grow Up
Dan CurrellCorporate Governance in the Age of Cyber Risks
In collaboration with RANE (Risk Assistance Network and Exchange)The Board’s Role in Managing Cybersecurity Risks
Ray A. Rothrock, James Kaplan, and Friso Van Der OordHiring For Cultural Fit At The Top
Eric J. McNultyAudit: Radical Change on the Horizon?
Stephen DavisHow Boards Can Create Inclusive Cultures for Organizations
Mike Fucci and Terri CooperDear Board Member: Your job just became even more important
Abby Adlerman and Mary CranstonThe Risks and Realities of Overboarding
Michael ToebeYour library is currently empty. Browse the Boardspan Library to get started.