What’s Going On At Tesla?
View in browser

2/8/24 – Issue 8.53 – Your weekly news on all things board. 

Directors Domain Header 22

Board members and the media alike are asking the same question this week: What is going on at Tesla? The Wall Street Journal obliged our curiosity by publishing a detailed story about Elon Musk’s relationship with his board at the automaker. The piece describes every facet of the Tesla board relationship, from the mundane to the outrageous. Other articles this week offer more information about the battle over Musk’s massive compensation package. Is the governance situation at Tesla sustainable? Time will tell. 

 

In other news, activists strike yet again at Disney; how corporate boards can prepare for a new administration; Adam Neumann pops up again to bid for WeWork; and the future of ESG in 2024.

 

In the Spotlight

 

Elon Musk’s Ties to Tesla Directors

Are the close relationships Musk has with his board members too close? 

 

“Board members at Elon Musk’s electric-car maker were facing a dilemma. One longtime director, the venture capitalist Steve Jurvetson, had left his firm after an internal investigation found he had slept with multiple women in the tech industry and used illegal drugs. Some of the details had been splashed across the press in 2017, and Tesla directors informally discussed how they should handle it, according to people familiar with the situation. Some urged him to resign.” THE WALL STREET JOURNAL

 

Does Elon Musk’s Compensation Ruling Undermine Board Governance?

What happens next with Tesla and Musk’s compensation package will play out in the courts

“It’s been a difficult last couple weeks for Tesla CEO Elon Musk. When it reported earnings at the end of last month, the electric car maker missed revenue and net income estimates, and projected its vehicle sales growth was likely to be lower in 2024. Share prices for the company dropped, with Musk briefly losing his standing as the world’s richest person. Then last week, a Delaware judge voided Musk’s $55.8 billion Tesla pay package, solidly moving him into the second-richest spot behind LVMH’s Bernard Arnault…While Musk is still CEO of Tesla and still a multibillionaire (Forbes estimates his current net worth at $182.6 billion), the ruling raises questions about corporate governance on the whole.” FORBES

 

What’s Next for the Tesla Board and Musk’s Pay Package

Board to determine Musk’s compensation while also demonstrating their independence

“For Elon Musk and the other seven members of Tesla’s board, the looming question now is: What next? Earlier this week, a Delaware judge ruled to void the Tesla chief executive’s $55.8 billion compensation package, putting both Musk and the company’s directors in a bind on how to proceed. Absent a win on appeal, which legal experts say could be challenging, board members face the prospect of having to rethink a pay deal for a billionaire chief executive who made Tesla the world’s most valuable automaker—all while under pressure to maintain an arm’s length.” THE WALL STREET JOURNAL

 

The Lawyer Who Took on Tesla

The lawyer–and drummer–who fought against Musk’s pay deal 

 

“The case that brought down Elon Musk’s multibillion-dollar pay package at Tesla was driven by a lawyer who spent decades representing big companies like Goldman Sachs and 21st Century Fox, and a shareholder who played drums in a heavy-metal band. The bombshell decision, issued Tuesday in the Delaware Court of Chancery, came more than five years after a Tesla shareholder originally filed suit, asking the state’s business-law court to cancel Musk’s pay package at the electric-car maker. The suit, filed in 2018, alleged that Tesla’s chief executive controlled the approval process and that the board misled investors, who later approved it. Musk has said he didn’t dictate the terms of his pay plan.” THE WALL STREET JOURNAL

 

From Boardspan this Week:

 

CEO Leadership Redefined

As CEOs chart their paths forward, they will need a different playbook for how to lead

 

"Increasingly, people are turning to the CEO for leadership on issues that go beyond the business-from climate change to social justice to public health. And, it’s not just employees wanting their CEO to speak out. The expectations that investors have of CEOs to take on complex societal issues are also changing. How CEOs address these issues through their words and actions can positively or negatively impact a company’s reputation.” HARVARD LAW SCHOOL FORUM ON CORPORATE GOVERNANCE via BOARDSPAN

 

Across the Board

 

Disney Activist Investor Officially Launches Proxy Fight, Nominates Three To Board

Disney has urged shareholders to vote only for its candidates

 

“Blackwells Capital today made its fight with Disney official, urging shareholders in a definitive proxy statement to elect its three nominees to the board of directors ‘as the company navigates through a vast and novel opportunity set offering a near limitless potential.’ ‘The purpose of our campaign is simple: we want to ensure that Disney has the right collection of minds around the boardroom table, working constructively together to make decisions that will benefit ALL shareholders for decades to come,’ Blackwells said. The firm is opposed to Nelson Peltz, whose Trian Partners is also taking on the Disney board in what is officially now a three-way fight. Both claim the company hasn’t delivered for stockholders recently.” DEADLINE

 

Who’s Who in the Battle Over Disney’s Board
Disney shares are trading at half the value held three years ago

 

“‘It is shaping up to be a contentious proxy season for Walt Disney. After several years of share price underperformance at the entertainment giant, at least three activist shareholders have launched proxy campaigns, with some hoping to get their own candidates elected on Disney’s board…Peltz and Iger have a history of butting heads. In January 2023, after a pronounced decline in Disney’s stock price, Peltz launched an activist campaign. Iger announced plans to cut 7,000 jobs and reduce spending by $5.5 billion, and Peltz dropped the campaign ahead of last year’s shareholder vote. Disney’s stock price continued to fall for much of last year, prompting Peltz to launch a new initiative. In the latest campaign called ‘Restore the Magic,’ Trian has said Disney lags behind its peers and has underperformed since Iger was appointed CEO in 2005.” THE WALL STREET JOURNAL

 

WeWork’s Co-Founder Is Trying to Buy the Company
Adam Neumann has sought for months to buy  business, to no avail

 

“Adam Neumann shot to fame by turning WeWork into a cultural and business phenomenon, before being ousted from the work space operator in dramatic fashion. But for the past several months, he has been trying to buy the now-bankrupt business — with the help of the hedge fund mogul Dan Loeb...Neumann’s new real estate company Flow Global is pushing WeWork to consider its takeover approach, according to a letter his lawyers sent to WeWork’s advisers on Monday. Flow which has already raised $350 million from the venture capital firm Andreessen Horowitz, disclosed in the letter that Loeb’s Third Point would help finance a transaction." THE NEW YORK TIMES

 

What Trends are Driving Cyber Risk in North America?
The resurgence of ransomware attacks in 2023 helped stoke worries for US organizations

 

“Generative artificial intelligence (AI), the resurgence of ransomware, an evolving regulatory environment, and a heated election year in the US are driving shifts in the cyber risk landscape for North American businesses this year. That’s as cyber incidents remained the most significant global risk for the third year in a row, according to the 2024 Allianz Risk Barometer. Cyber events are the top peril in 17 countries, including the US, and the second-biggest risk in Canada. Business leaders polled by Allianz were most concerned about data breaches (59%), attacks on critical infrastructure and physical assets (53%), and ransomware (53%).” INSURANCE BUSINESS

 

The Future of ESG: Thoughts for Boards and Management in 2024

Boards and management begin navigating toward a post-ESG era

“The term ‘ESG’ has steadily faded from the investor and corporate lexicon over the past year in the wake of cultural and political clashes over its meaning and purpose.  ‘Anti-ESG’ legislation adopted by several states has created legal and financial hurdles around the term.  Institutional investors have gone quiet on ESG amid public criticism and congressional subpoenas.  BlackRock has publicly disavowed the term for having become too politicized.  The use of ‘ESG’ in earnings calls has dropped precipitously. For boards and management seeking to navigate today’s environment, the declining use of the term ‘ESG’ likely signals its evolution rather than its demise.” HARVARD LAW SCHOOL FORUM ON CORPORATE GOVERNANCE

 

Harvard Names Ex-Merck CEO and KKR Co-CEO to Board

Neither Ackman’s candidate nor Zuckerberg’s got the votes

 

“Harvard University named two top business executives to its governing board at a time of intense scrutiny of the institution from alumni, lawmakers and faculty. Kenneth Frazier, the former chief executive officer of Merck & Co., and KKR & Co. Co-CEO Joseph Bae, were elected Sunday by Harvard Corp. with the consent of the board of overseers, according to a statement from Alan M. Garber, the university’s interim president.” BLOOMBERG

 

Singapore has High Potential to be an AI Hub

Experts cite AI Trailblazers and strong public/partnerships as leading-edge initiatives

 

“Singapore has ‘very high’ potential as a global AI hub — thanks in part to an environment that fosters innovation, a Google Cloud executive told CNBC…Yap was speaking on the sidelines of Explore AI summit in January, a meeting hosted by Google Cloud and the Singapore government to recognize the top generative AI solutions from organizations that took part in the ‘AI Trailblazers’ initiative. The initiative was first announced in July by Singapore’s Ministry of Communications and Information, Digital Industry Singapore, Smart Nation and Digital Government Office, and Google Cloud.” CNBC

 

Should Your Board Prepare For A Potential Commercial Real Estate Crisis?

New York Community Bancorp recorded unexpected commercial real estate losses this month

 

“New York Community Bancorp’s sharp stock price decline this week is an early indication that corporate board members may need to thoroughly examine whether their company has any potential exposure to banks (or other investments) that could be affected by a commercial real estate crisis. Industry analysts are warning that a commercial property meltdown is coming, and banks that hold a significant level of commercial real estate loans may be at risk of default. As we saw last year, bank defaults can disrupt companies in numerous ways, and corporate boards should have mitigation strategies in place to help their company navigate any disruptions if necessary.” CORPORATE BOARD MEMBER

    Seat at the Table

    • Mattel appoints to its board Julius Genachowski, Senior Advisor at Carlyle; and Dawn Ostroff, former Chief Content & Advertising Business Officer at Spotify 

    • BlackBerry welcomes to its board Philip Brace, former President and CEO of Sierra Wireless

    • AIG announces to its board Chris Inglis, former White House National Cyber Director

    • Rocket Companies welcomes to its board Alex Rampell, General Partner at Andreessen Horowitz

    • Etsy announces to its board Marc Steinberg, Partner at Elliott Investment Management

    • HSBC USA elects to its board Edith Avilés, former Vice Chairman and Executive Committee Member for the Americas division of investment firm Natixis

    • Vail Resorts appoints to its board Iris Knobloch, President of the Cannes Film Festival

    • Magnolia Oil & Gas Corporation elects to its board David Khani, former CFO of EQT Corporation

    • Oportun appoints to its board Carlos Minetti, former President of Consumer Banking at Discover Financial Services; and Mohit Daswani, CFO of ThoughtSpot

    • Frontier Communications Parent welcomes to its board Woody Young, former Chairman of Mergers and Acquisitions at Perella Weinberg Partners

    • Midland States Bancorp elects to its board Gerald Carlson, former Managing Partner of KPMG

    • Ameris Bancorp appoints to its board Claire McLean, COO and EVP of Preferred Capital Securities

    • Rockwell Automation elects to its board Timothy Knavish, Chairman and CEO of paints and materials firm PPG

    LinkedIn
    X
    Facebook

    About Boardspan
    Boardspan is the leading provider of digital governance solutions for boards across all sectors. Our cloud-based assessments, benchmarking analytics and governance education programs complement our board search and advisory services to deliver a holistic approach to governance. Boards of all sizes and stages rely on Boardspan to deliver analytics, insights and outcomes that improve their effectiveness and performance. Clients include KKR, The Kellogg Foundation, Ingersoll Rand, Farfetch, McAfee, Beyond Meat, Box, e.l.f. Beauty, Satellite Healthcare and the U.S. Olympic & Paralympic Committee.

    Copyright © 2023 Boardspan. All rights reserved.

    Boardspan updates its Privacy Policy in response to evolving best practices and regulatory requirements, such as GDPR. We value transparency and like to share these policies for use of our website and other information we offer.

    Boardspan, 3000 El Camino Real, Bldg. 4 Suite 200, Palo Alto, CA 94306, USA

    Unsubscribe Manage preferences